What Happens When a Gas Regulator Fails? (Explained)

Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning we get a small commission if you make a purchase through our links, at no cost to you. For more information, please visit our Disclaimer Page.

Despite careful installation and maintenance, some gas regulators still fail.

A malfunctioning gas regulator safety valve on your gas regulator could not detect a burning heating system and, thus, allow gas to escape rather than shut off as it should.

Gas pressure regulator with manometer, isolated with clipping pa

Can Gas Regulators Fail?

In general, internal failures result in the release of regulated gases into the atmosphere. The failure of a significant component does not appear imminent. Regulators are usually concerned about two things.

Firstly, the diaphragm and external ports can leak gas into the atmosphere. If someone has changed the factory fittings or gauges or lowered the torque settings than they should be, there is rarely any leakage from the ports.

Changes to connections can damage port threads, resulting in leakage. A flexible, dynamic component, diaphragms move axially whenever gas flows or pressure fluctuates through a regulator.

The pressurization and relaxation of a diaphragm constitute two consecutive cycles. Those made of metallic materials must have a minimum life of 10,000 cycles. In the advanced stages of a diaphragm failure, leakage can occur from the diaphragm.

In general, elastomeric diaphragms are more susceptible to this than metal diaphragms. Gas can escape the atmosphere through the vent hole on the bonnet in the case of the flexed metal diaphragm.

Continuing with the regulator failure theme, an internally leaking regulator, sometimes called creeping or crawling, happens frequently.

For example, when a foreign material such as a metal chip or piece of plastic damages or displaces the seat. It is not possible to maintain delivery pressure and regulator pressure when the seat is not entirely closed.

If the safety relief mechanism of the regulator is not activated, the downstream or delivery pressure will continue to rise. In this case, you can use a gauge that displays regulated pressure to check for such a failure.

Upon exceeding the setpoint, the gauge pressure will rise—any downstream equipment exposed to these pressures above the rated limit to a potentially hazardous condition. Ensure to perform the visual checks of regulators for failures frequently.

What Happens When a Gas Regulator Fails?

Gas regulator safety valves may malfunction if they cannot detect the presence of a flame and can continue to release gas even when there is no flame instead of shutting off. Gas vapors can leak into a home in such instances.

Colorado Springs Utilities states that natural gas has an unpleasant smell and can cause lightheadedness, nausea, and coughing. Sparks and flames can ignite the vapors when enough gas builds up, resulting in an explosion.

How Do I Know If My Gas Regulator Is Bad?

Gas regulators regulate gas to flow out of high-pressure cylinders to ensure the level of gas is safe and appropriate for using the equipment.

As a result, gas regulators perform a wide range of duties from welding to dental equipment, from gas grills to engines.

You can check your system for these signs if you believe your gas regulator is acting up. The following signs indicate that you need a new gas regulator.


Blue flames indicate that a propane appliance is operating if you use propane to power it. Your regulator is at fault if you see yellow instead of blue flames if your stove or grill is lit.

Low pressure in the gas grill regulator may also result in this problem. Propane pressure regulators that are functioning will produce blue flames that are level with the burner.

A blue flame, a roar, and a tall height, on the other hand, indicate high pressure in the LP gas regulator. Flares are the greatest indicator of a problem with natural gas regulators, no matter how you look at them. It may be necessary to troubleshoot the propane regulator on an RV as a result.

Sooty Residue

Another sign that you need to fix or replace your propane gas regulator is soot accumulation on your burner. The flame of propane burns cleanly, and it doesn’t produce dark smoke when it burns.

The burner on your heater, stove, or fireplace might be malfunctioning if you notice dark spots on the surface and blackened residue. It may be necessary to replace the pressure regulator in a propane tank if adjusting the heat doesn’t make a difference.

The combustion of propane is clean and quiet, as mentioned above. Turning off your burners, does it make popping noises? If so, this means either you need to replace the gas valve regulator or replace the burners. After doing the change, the popping noises will cease.

No Propane Flow

It stands to reason that the burners won’t work if propane is not flowing through your system. The regulator pressure of the propane grill can be extremely low, which leads to this problem. Another possibility is that the safety mechanism in the regulator is malfunctioning.

The regulator automatically shuts off the safety valve when it detects a high propane flow, similar to the feature on propane tanks. Shut off propane tanks and all propane appliances to reset the propane regulator.

Faulty Vents and Leaking

When using your appliances, you may notice a smell of propane indicating a leak in the regulator. To ensure there are no leaks, use soapy dishwater to spray or pour over the regulator.

You will notice bubbles when a leak starts developing. On the bottom of the regulator, there are vents as well. They keep the regulator from overheating by allowing it to breathe.

Besides acting as a safety feature, it also prevents overfilled tanks from developing too high pressure. A new regulator may be required if you notice an overfilled tank.

Automatic Changeover is Malfunctioning

A propane auto-regulating appliance with dual propane tanks will fit on this. As soon as the new regulator you have installed, the appliance will automatically switch to the second tank, so there is no need to do anything.

You may notice a red tank level indicator that won’t reset. It shows that your regulator is seriously malfunctioning when it produces weak and yellow flames. A malfunctioning automatic system could indicate a malfunctioning regulator.

It’s Frozen

When appliances haven’t been maintained over the winter or in very cold climates, this can happen. A buildup of frost around your water heater or fireplace regulator is a good indication it requires replacement.

Regulators in propane tanks freeze frequently and are not difficult to fix. Condensation from melting frost causes the problem. If the damage of the regulator is because of water, a serious malfunction can result.

Gas valve regulator

How Often Should Gas Regulators Be Replaced?

I recommend replacing gas regulators every five years. It is very important to use a regulator and gas hose to effectively and safely use gas. Gas cylinders store gas, but to use it, you need to supply it.

Gas hoses and regulators are necessary for gas supply to be effective and efficient. Each time you use the gas, you should examine the hose and regulator for malfunctions or damages.


You should perform a regular check for external leaks and internal leaks on all compressed gas regulators. You should send the device out for service at least once every five years and send it back to the manufacturer or a competent agent for inspection and refurbishment.

Labels or tags should identify the last inspection date of regulators as well. To determine the frequency of testing external and internal leakage, consult the manufacturer.

Since some devices are still in service while others are not, it isn’t easy to speculate when and how to replace them. The company literature may include service-life guidelines that outline what will happen during the lifetime of the product.

To prevent the dangers caused by regulator failures, users should closely follow these guidelines. Therefore, if your gas regulator is not working properly, you should try fixing it.

If you know about gas regulators, you can replace them yourself, but try contacting the professionals if you are inexperienced.